From Discovery to Research
Stock Sage's Friday scan helps identify companies that meet the applicable fundamental and 52-week-low screening criteria. Finding the company is only the first stage.
Once a company appears in Today's Results, the investor should begin investigating why the stock is trading where it is and whether the business deserves continued consideration.
- 1
Stock Sage Discovery
- 2
Open Company Research
- 3
Examine Fundamentals
- 4
Examine Valuation
- 5
Examine Price Context
- 6
Consider the Information Together
- 7
Continue Research / Watch / Take No Action
The First Question: Why Is the Stock Near Its Low?
Before examining individual numbers, ask: “Why is this stock trading near its 52-week low?”
A lower price can occur for very different reasons, including:
- Temporary market weakness
- Industry weakness
- A disappointing earnings report
- Slowing business growth
- Declining profitability
- Company-specific problems
- A previously excessive valuation becoming more reasonable
- Broader economic or market conditions
Do not assume either that “the market must be wrong” or that “the company must be bad.” The purpose of research is to investigate the reason for the lower price.
Start With Five-Year EPS
Earnings Per Share, or EPS, represents the portion of a company's earnings attributable to each outstanding share. Stock Sage already requires at least 4 of the previous 5 years to have positive EPS for fundamental qualification.
After qualification, look beyond simply counting positive years. Examine the pattern.
Pattern A
Year 1
$2.10
Year 2
$2.35
Year 3
$2.60
Year 4
$2.90
Year 5
$3.20
This shows a generally rising five-year EPS pattern.
Pattern B
Year 1
$3.20
Year 2
$2.90
Year 3
$2.50
Year 4
$2.10
Year 5
$1.70
EPS remains positive, but the declining pattern may deserve investigation.
Pattern C
Year 1
$2.00
Year 2
$2.30
Year 3
-$0.40
Year 4
$2.50
Year 5
$2.80
This company could satisfy Stock Sage's 4-of-5 positive EPS requirement, but the negative year should still be investigated.
Passing the EPS Screen Asks
Was EPS positive in at least four of five years?
EPS Research Asks
What has been happening to the company's earnings over those five years?
Examining Total Assets and Total Liabilities
Stock Sage requires Total Assets to be greater than Total Liabilities in each of the five years examined. Assets represent resources controlled by the company. Liabilities represent financial obligations owed by the company.
The screening rule provides a basic balance-sheet qualification, but research should go beyond simply confirming that the company passed. Where the information is available, ask whether assets are generally increasing, whether liabilities are increasing, and whether the difference between assets and liabilities is becoming larger or smaller.
The requirement does not mean the company has no debt or financial risk.
Understanding Profit Margin
Profit margin shows how much of a company's revenue ultimately becomes profit. If a company generates $100 in revenue and ultimately earns $12 in profit, its profit margin is approximately 12%.
Profit-margin information can help investors investigate how effectively a company converts sales into profits. Where historical information is available, consider whether the margin is improving, relatively stable, or declining.
Different industries naturally operate with different profit margins. A margin should not automatically be labeled good or bad simply because it is high or low; consider the company, its history, and its industry.
Understanding Book Value
Book value generally reflects the accounting value of a company's assets after liabilities are considered. It can provide useful context, but its usefulness varies substantially by type of business.
For businesses with significant tangible assets, book value may provide one kind of context. For businesses whose value depends heavily on intellectual property, software, brands, networks, or other intangible assets, book value may tell only part of the story.
Book value is one piece of information—not a complete valuation method by itself. A stock below book value is not automatically inexpensive.
Understanding Dividend Yield
Dividend yield compares the annual dividend paid by a company with the current stock price. It can be useful to investors interested in income, but a higher yield is not automatically better.
A stock's dividend yield can rise because the dividend increased or because the stock price declined. An unusually high dividend yield may therefore deserve additional research.
Investors should consider whether the company's earnings and financial position appear capable of supporting the dividend. No dividend is guaranteed.
Understanding Stock Buybacks
A stock buyback occurs when a company repurchases some of its own shares. One potential effect is reducing the number of shares outstanding.
Buybacks can be useful information, but they should not automatically be interpreted as proof that management believes the stock is undervalued. Consider buybacks together with earnings, financial condition, valuation, and other available company information.
A buyback is something to investigate—not a stand-alone reason to purchase a stock.
Historical P/E and Current P/E
Historical valuation information lets an investor ask not only “What is the company's P/E today?” but also “How does today's valuation compare with the company's own historical valuation?”
Fictional Example One
Historical P/E: low 14, high 28
Current P/E: 16
The current P/E is closer to the lower end of this company's fictional historical range. That may make it worth investigating further, but does not establish that it is undervalued or should be purchased.
Fictional Example Two
Historical P/E: low 12, high 24
Current P/E: 35
Even after falling significantly from its 52-week high, this stock's current valuation could remain above its historical P/E range.
A stock can be near its 52-week low and still not be inexpensive relative to its own historical valuation.
When P/E Can Be Misleading
P/E is useful but imperfect. A low P/E can occur because investors expect earnings to decline. A high P/E can reflect expectations for significant future growth. Temporary earnings changes can also distort P/E.
If earnings are extremely small or negative, P/E may be less useful or unavailable.
52-Week High and Low
The 52-week high and low provide price context. The low shows approximately where the stock's lowest price has been during the previous year; the high shows the other end of that range.
Stock Sage focuses on companies near the lower end of their own range, but the previous high is not a future price target.
Analyst Estimates and 12-Month Price-Target Information
When analyst estimates or price-target information is available within Stock Sage, it can provide another perspective on market expectations.
Analyst estimates are opinions and forecasts. They can change, they can be wrong, and different analysts can reach different conclusions. Consider them alongside other research rather than treating them as guaranteed future prices.
Financial Statements and Cash Flow
Company research can also include financial-statement information available within Stock Sage. Each major statement contributes a different kind of context.
Income Statement
Shows information about the company's revenue, expenses, and profitability over a period of time.
Balance Sheet
Shows information about what the company owns and owes at a particular point in time.
Cash Flow Statement
Shows how cash moves into and out of the business.
Accounting earnings and cash generation are related but are not identical. These statements provide context for the simpler metrics shown elsewhere in Stock Sage.
Free Cash Flow
If free-cash-flow information is available within Stock Sage, it generally represents cash generated by the business after accounting for capital expenditures necessary to maintain or grow the business.
Investors may examine free cash flow because reported accounting earnings and actual cash generation can differ. Where historical information is available, investigate whether it appears consistently positive, improving, declining, or highly inconsistent.
There is no required free-cash-flow threshold in this lesson, and positive free cash flow does not guarantee a good investment. If Stock Sage displays free cash flow after dividends, use the application's displayed terminology when interpreting that information rather than creating a new calculation.
Putting the Information Together
No single metric should determine the conclusion.
- 1
Earnings
What is happening to EPS?
- 2
Balance Sheet
What is happening to assets and liabilities?
- 3
Profitability
What is happening to profit margin?
- 4
Valuation
How does the current valuation compare with history?
- 5
Price Context
Where is the stock within its 52-week range, and why?
- 6
Cash Flow
What does available cash-flow information show?
- 7
Estimates
What are available analyst expectations suggesting?
- 8
Investigate the Story
Why are these numbers changing?
Numbers tell you what happened. Research helps you investigate why.
Fictional Company Research Example
Sage Industrial Systems (SIS) is a fictional company used only for this educational example.
Five-Year EPS
$2.10 · $2.35 · $2.55 · $2.80 · $3.05
Observation: EPS has been positive and generally increasing.
Balance Sheet
Total Assets exceeded Total Liabilities in all five years.
Observation: SIS passes Stock Sage's basic balance-sheet qualification.
Profit Margin
Five years ago: 8%
Most recent year: 11%
Observation: Profit margin has improved in this fictional example.
52-Week Range
Low: $42 · High: $76 · Current: $45
Observation: The stock is near the lower end of its 52-week range.
Historical P/E
Historical low: 13 · Historical high: 24 · Current: 14
Observation: Current P/E is near the lower end of the company's fictional historical range.
A Second Example: Why a Low Price May Not Be Enough
Example Technologies (EXT) is another fictional company. Its five-year EPS is $4.20, $4.00, $3.50, $2.80, and $2.10. All five years are positive. Total Assets exceed Total Liabilities in all five years, and the stock is near its 52-week low. EXT could therefore satisfy the basic Stock Sage screening requirements.
EPS has nevertheless declined from $4.20 to $2.10. The company passes the positive-EPS count, but the earnings trend raises an important research question:
Why are earnings declining?
This demonstrates why Stock Sage qualification is the beginning of research rather than the end.
What Should You Do After the Research?
Completing research does not require the investor to make a trade. Possible outcomes include:
- Continue researching the company
- Add it to the Personal Watchlist
- Continue monitoring its price and fundamentals
- Compare it with other opportunities
- Investigate options where appropriate
- Decide it does not currently deserve further attention
- Take no action
A Repeatable Stock Research Routine
- 1Why is it near its 52-week low?
- 2What does the five-year EPS trend show?
- 3What do assets and liabilities show?
- 4What is happening to profitability?
- 5How does current valuation compare with historical valuation?
- 6What does the 52-week range tell me about price context?
- 7What does available cash-flow information show?
- 8What do available analyst estimates suggest?
- 9What risks or changes explain the current price?
- 10Does this company deserve continued research?
Knowledge Check
Choose an answer for each question, then check your response.